Pink Tape

A BLOG FROM THE FAMILY BAR

...in which I ricochet from too serious to too flippant and where I may vent, rant or wax lyrical at my own whim, mostly about family law. Constructive co-ranting welcome. More...

Newsletter

Publication of adverse findings against professional witnesses – helpful Court of Appeal clarification

There is, in my experience, often much consternation about what is required when a judge makes adverse criticism or findings in respect of a professional or expert witness, and then proposes to publish that judgment, particularly if the proposal is that the professional in question should be named. Read carefully Re W [2016] provides the answer, but it often isn’t read carefully and I think it’s effect is frequently overstated (its often interpreted as requiring everyone to be notified and potentially intervened wherever there is a possibility of an adverse finding, which is never what Re W said).

The Judicial Press Office has just circulated this judgment of the Court of Appeal: E (A Child) [2025] EWCA Civ 1563 which, although only a permission judgment, they have specifically said is citable, in order to provide some clarification on this vexed topic. That clarification is welcome.

The headline is:

We consider it important to emphasise the exceptional nature of Re W and to underline the following. A witness of fact will generally have no legitimate ground of appeal in respect of adverse findings contained in a judgment, provided the criticisms have been fairly put to the witness in cross-examination for comment or response before the findings are made. A witness who is at risk of adverse findings does not, for that reason, have any right to intervene or to have legal representation.

Other points to note are:

  • the distinction between challenge to the substantive findings and the proposed publication (a failure to be clear about this appears to have contributed heavily to the refusal to grant permission – the witness did not challenge the findings at the point they were made, instead she implicitly accepted them, before seeking later to challenge them on appeal,
  • the limited relevance of article 6 in respect of a non party whose civil rights and obligations are not being determined – the key issue is that if an article 8 point is live any findings made need to have been reached by a fair process : “The cases show that the adverse portrayal of an individual’s conduct in an authoritative judicial ruling may cause serious harm to that individual’s reputation amounting to an interference with the right to respect for private life which is guaranteed by Article 8 of the Convention; and if those findings have been arrived at by an unfair process the interference may not be justified.”,
  • the reiteration of the guidance in Re W that putting points to a witness in cross examination IS sufficient notice of the possibility of adverse findings (Re W was unusual in that there was no such cross examination or questions by the judge and nobody anticipated findings being made, even the parties / their legal representatives),
  • the reminder of the difficulties associated with an attempt to raise new points on appeal that were not taken below,
  • the reminder that the Denton relief from sanctions approach will be applied to applications for permission to appeal out of time, so good justification is required.

The judgment isn’t yet on the judiciary or National Archives site, and nor is the decision below of Henke J, but I’m told it will be up soon [update – link to permission judgment now added above – can’t see the decision below yet].

I probably could publish the judgment here, but am a bit anxious about doing that just in case there is some correction…

The professional concerned is a psychotherapist and there is reference to her ‘regulatory body’ being provided with the findings (this was not apparently disputed). I’m not aware that psychotherapists have a regulatory body, so either this is a slightly inaccurate description of a membership body for psychotherapists OR this professional is also a member of a regulated profession, for example a clinical or counselling psychologist, in which case she would be regulated by the HCPC. [update: she is not a regulated psychologist, but is a member of the BACP (British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy), who do have a complaints scheme applicable to those psychotherapists who choose to be members https://www.bacp.co.uk/about-us/protecting-the-public/].

Please don’t confuse your ‘usual practice’ with my actual reading of the actual rules

Alright you slackers, it's time for some law. Mainly because I have had a bunch of browser windows open with 'new' judgments open, ready for me to write them up and I can't tick them off my to do list until I do. I could just close the browser windows but that would be cheating. So, here is judgment number 1. In Re T (Adoption Hearing: Involvement of Applicants) [2024] EWCA Civ 189 the Court of Appeal corrected an erroneous practice in Cornwall relating to adoption hearings. The appeal judges thought (and I agree - for what that's worth) that this was probably not confined to Cornwall, much as other creative interpretations of other procedural requirements have turned out to be widespread in other cases (think the Somerset cases about adoption regulations and medicals a few years ago - very much not confined to Somerset, and in fact there were variations on the theme in a number of counties which were revealed and corrected only when others got wind of the Somerset case). Here, the...

read more

What are we doing with our lives?

I've been cautious about posting anything recently. My head is awl of a muddle and I may say something I will later regret. But I've got itchy fingers and am sitting quietly at home with nobody to distract me, so... I should be at work this week. In fact I should be in the middle of week one of three. I am (now) glad that I'm not, but this time last week I was frankly very, very cross. Not cross at anyone in particular, except possibly myself. But really hacked off at the job and the nonsense it involves. I wasn't feeling very rational about it last week, so resisted the urge to do a bit of keyboard warrioring until I'd slept on it. A few times. But there is a rump of residual frustration still with me that I am pretty sure is nothing to do with my current grief induced irrationality. This. Bloody. Job. Sucks. As Dickens almost certainly wrote in Bleak house: it is the best of jobs. And it is the worst of jobs. When mum died I was in the middle of prepping for the 3 week trial. There...

read more

I have run out of vases

Trigger warning: death.   My mum died last week. Her name was Suzanne (never Susan). I realised as I studied her face after it happened that I have never seen a dead body before. Her top lip was taut over her teeth. She looked weirdly waxen. Her forehead was cool on my lips as I kissed her goodbye. Right now I am learning a lot about the stuff that needs to be sorted when someone dies. There is a lot of it. And I am learning a lot too about the enormity of losing a parent. I can't quite make sense of the fact that it is both something that almost everyone goes through at my stage of life if not before (i.e. quite normal really), but is also uniquely, overwhelmingly painful (does not feel at all normal) all at the same time. I think they call this cognitive dissonance. Whatever it is, it's raging right now. I'm three days in. The doorbell keeps ringing and flowers keep appearing. The house is full of flowers. But is notably minus one mum. We are waiting for the van to collect...

read more

What my out of office really means…

The other day I put a polite but hopefully firm OOO on my emails, explaining that I am not taking on new work and will deal only with emails relating to existing commitments. This morning I seriously contemplated rewording it to simply read: "For the love of god, STOP. EMAILING. ME!" I flirted with the idea of adding some swears as a parting flourish (I love a good swear, it's therapeutic). Of course, I haven't done that. It's nobody else's fault that I need to draw a line. And they aren't psychic. Also, I am a professional. But I have reached a stage where for the sake of my sanity and those around me, and to make sure I do right by my clients, my family and myself, I need to impose some serious boundaries. Otherwise I am at risk of providing a poor standard of work, parenting, partnering and daughtering. So I'm pausing on new commitments. All of them. Our household, our whole family is undergoing a period of acute difficulty, following on from a period of chronic stress and change,...

read more

Two more books, still working on that novel…

Hot on the heels of the second edition of Transparency in the Family Courts, released last week, I received these beauties in the post today. The Public Law Dictionary is a new addition to this family of dictionaries, and I am one of the authors. Other titles include Private Law, TLATA and Inheritance Act, and Financial Remedies. It feels good to have both projects off my to do list, all finished and on my desk in glossy covered hard copy. You can buy a copy of the Dictionaries via Class Legal here. They come in print or ebook format (including pdf if you prefer that), and the digital versions are a bit cheaper at £65. For those who asked about discounts for the Transparency Book - the publishers for that, Bloomsbury, have kindly provided a discount code for junior FLBA members - check your inbox for that code as it went out in a recent FLBA mail out.   Anyway, that's me done with legal textbooks for a while (although I have a further book project that I have long promised to...

read more

About this blog

“Pink Tape” isn’t just about family law. I post about topics that interest me, which mostly revolve around family law, but also include non-legal family-related topics as well as unrelated subjects. I hope this blog will convince at least one person that not all of us in the legal profession are money-hungry sharks. Some of us are actually quite nice. Additionally, I aim to provide useful information about family law for those working in the field without being too heavy or boring.

The primary goal of the blog is to improve the quality of public information and discussions about legal issues.

I understand that not everyone is a fan of “Pink Tape” or family lawyers in general.

latest

Blog Posts

Take your time, we’ve got all decade…

I have been writing and talking about the need for a prohibition on cross examination in the family court since at least 2016 (see here and here). 2016 was the year that the Prison and Courts Bill contained almost identical provisions to those eventually passed in...

Logically speaking

This blog post is a logic experiment. It’s not about individual cases. It’s just an attempt to work through some possible consequences of our shifts in practice over the last few years in cases involving domestic abuse, and what that might – must? – mean when you work...

The unintended consequences of law – a postscript

Not long ago I wrote a tiresomely long post about what I will call the transparency in financial remedy (FR) cases, a topic about which there has been much recent debate (see Very Much Ancillary, published here and elsewhere). Others may quibble about the use of the...

Very much ancillary

A lot has been written of late about the privacy (or otherwise) of family money cases, and all of it by men with big brains and a lot of words. As someone who hasn’t conducted a money case for some years (not great with numbers, me), I would not dare to offer any view...

Panorama – Protecting Our Children – A Balancing Act

Ironically, given the title, the preponderant comment I've seen about this Panorama (even before it was aired tonight) is a complaint about a lack of balance. Social workers (because it did seem mainly to be social workers making such comments on my social media when...

Self-reflective learning journal (aka navel gazing)

Fresh back from a CPD weekend and I'm full of ideas for blog posts, albeit slightly tired and emotional (there may have been some socialising too - the children keep correcting me when I say I've been away for work: 'No mum, you've been to a party!'). Anyway, high...

Lying lawyers – when is a lawyer misleading the court?

It's not uncommon to see litigants complaining on social media about lawyers lying on behalf of their clients. It's almost as common to see lawyers getting a bit twisty about those complaints, and feeling affronted at the suggestion. This is because honesty is...

Beware free lunches

When I first wrote the Family Court without a Lawyer back in 2009 I didn't write it for McKenzie friends to use, but I do know that over the years many have bought it, have come to rely upon on it and to recommend it. Those who have read it will know that in the book...

Delayed Reaction…

Today's mediocre blog post is brought to you from the Sunday sofa of covid...(actually, its probably just a mild non-covidy virus, but confirmation is awaited)... I blame any typos, non-sequiturs, offence or error on the wretched germs. I did read the President's Case...

Rules of the blog

Anonymized or fictional

All the information on this blog is anonymized or fictional to avoid causing any trouble for anyone, including myself. I have modified details to prevent the identification of specific cases.

Comments

 I won’t approve comments that, in my judgment, breach privacy laws related to family matters. Unless individuals have been identified in a published judgment, I won’t disclose their involvement in any proceedings.

Nothing Defamatory

 I will not post anything that I believe could be considered defamatory. Due to time constraints, I can’t fact-check every statement in a comment. Therefore, I must be cautious to prevent potential legal issues or threatening letters. If you’re certain that a comment is not defamatory, you can publish it elsewhere at your own risk.

NOT Legal Advice

The content of this blog is not intended to constitute legal advice, so please don’t interpret it as such. It may seem relevant to your situation, but it likely isn’t. I cannot be held responsible for any reliance you place on its contents.

Accuracy

The information on the blog is as accurate and up to date as possible, considering my other commitments. Pink Tape is a hobby that I work on when time allows. Therefore, I can’t cover all legal changes or update information that becomes outdated.

External Links

I cannot be held responsible for the content of external sites linked from this blog, in terms of their accuracy or the opinions expressed on them

Moderation

I’ve implemented comment moderation on this blog to filter out comments that are repeatedly negative or offensive about lawyers. Rest assured, I won’t block sensible contributions, even if they disagree with me. I will strive to moderate promptly, but occasionally a comment may get lost in spam.

Right of Reply

If a post contains an inaccuracy about you and you’d like it corrected, feel free to comment for a right of reply. Please respect that the content on this blog is my intellectual property, and ask for permission before reposting. If you have any topics or blog post suggestions, feel free to email me at familoo@pinktape.co.uk.

Copyright

All material on this site is copyright of Lucy Reed. Please do not reproduce without permission.