Pink Tape

A BLOG FROM THE FAMILY BAR

...in which I ricochet from too serious to too flippant and where I may vent, rant or wax lyrical at my own whim, mostly about family law. Constructive co-ranting welcome. More...

Newsletter

Court Service Cover Up?

NB I think this post was accidentally published yesterday in half finished form, something that has never happened before. It probably didn’t make a lot of sense. However, this is now the tidied and completed version.

The BBC Headline reads:

Courts service ‘covered up’ IT bug that caused evidence to go missing

The report claims that the upshot is that ‘judges in civil, family and tribunal courts will have made rulings on cases when evidence was incomplete.’ This news is pretty alarming, isn’t it? But also somewhat impenetrable. What does it actually mean? What was missing? How often did it happen? How important was it and did judges know information was missing? Because all we have is a news report about a leaked internal report, the detail is pretty much absent. The report tells us that the software concerned is ‘known variously as Judicial Case Manager, MyHMCTS or CCD – is used to manage evidence and track cases before the courts. It is used by judges, lawyers, case workers and members of the public.’ I *think* that this encompasses the ‘portal’ that lawyers and judges now use to upload and access documents in public law children cases (why the same system has to have a bunch of different names is anyone’s guess), but in any event the fact that there are bugs in this system is certainly NOT a revelation. There have always been bugs in the system. Even if a document IS on the portal it isn’t always easy to find (though this lack of navigability is somewhat reduced with recent updates). Even before the portal we had analogue version of ‘missing documents’ problems – witness bundles that had been delivered and signed for were forever disappearing in a black hole, never to be found again, and judges were often not provided with copies of documents filed by email to the required court inbox, because there were not enough staff to check the inbox and forward them to the judge in time for the hearing (actually these last two still happen). So, to that extent this is not news. Twas ever thus. Here though is what is said specifically about family courts:

In the family courts, a different IT flaw caused thousands of documents to go missing, sources say.

In one instance, it is claimed a fault caused more than 4,000 documents to go missing from hundreds of public family law cases – including child protection cases.

The BBC understands this bug was discovered in 2023 and may have been present for some years. We have been told it has since been resolved but that no investigation was carried out to establish potential impact on case outcomes.

We asked the MoJ if any emergency child protection cases had been affected.

It did not respond to this question.

I’d like an answer to this question. I hope one will be forthcoming, but other than the quotes in this piece (regurgitated in other papers and online sources) I haven’t seen any substantive response from the MOJ / HMCTS, and certainly no announcement of further enquiry (see MOJ page here, where press releases are usually found, and HMCTS here). The vibe is very much ‘nothing to see here!’… Former President of the Family Division is alarmed though, saying:

These hearings often decide the fate of people’s lives…An error could mean the difference between a child being removed from an unsafe environment or a vulnerable person missing out on benefits.

I suppose that is true, but fortunately there are safeguards, at least in those cases involving lawyers – which is always the case in public law (Child protection) cases, where all the main players will be publicly funded. Those problems identified above were and are worked around by checking the judge has right documents and by forwarding those she does not. The lawyers will a) compile the bundle, making sure it has the key documents in it b) make sure the judge has it c) direct the judge to the key documents within it (in their case summary or reading list or orally at the start of the hearing and d) ensure that in the judge’s reasoned decision there is reference to those key documents, if not explicitly some indication that they have been read. In the course of a trial there are plenty of opportunities for a document that has gone astray or been missed by the judge to be identified as missing, provided to the judge and read. In cases where there are no lawyers (or where a key player doesn’t have a lawyer), or in urgent hearings there is a greater risk that a document is missing and this is not identified. Even then, if the document is obviously key to the decision the judge has to make, they are likely to identify that they need it and to ask for it it. So, whilst Sir James is right in principle – in practice, I am not so sure we should all panic and assume that many miscarriages of justice have flowed from this disastrous IT failure.
It is still obviously right to call it a disaster though, because the point is, even if I am pretty sanguine about it, we just don’t know. And individual litigants just don’t know. And will rightly be worried about it, fretting that it might have made all the difference to their family, their child. So too, they will understandably see this as more evidence of a system that is at best systemically broken and at worst corrupt and self serving. Why weren’t these issues identified and shared with stakeholders until a leak brought them to public attention with the help of the media? And why have HMCTS / MOJ not even considered the question about impact on individual child protection cases even been thought sufficiently serious to warrant an attempt at an answer?
That for me is almost the biggest worry. the lack of transparency and the failure of accountability, or of any recognition of how much impact these issues would have on public trust and confidence, mutliplied fourfold when they emerge through apparent whistleblowing rather than voluntarily. The passage in the BBC report about the ‘culture of cover up’ is most alarming:

The BBC has spoken to several separate sources within HMCTS who liken the situation to the Horizon Post Office scandal, where executives tried to suppress evidence of the system’s flaws.

One says there was “general horror” at the design of the software, introduced by HMCTS in 2018, which they claim was “not designed properly or robustly” and had a long history of data loss.

Another says there was a general reluctance from senior management to “acknowledge or face the reality” of the situation, despite repeated warnings from the agency’s IT staff.

“There is a culture of cover-ups,” one told the BBC. “They’re not worried about risk to the public, they’re worried about people finding out about the risk to the public. It’s terrifying to witness.”

When asked, the MoJ told us several organisations had been involved in the design and development of the software but did not supply a list.

I expect – hope – we may hear more about this in due course. I hope we do, if for no other reason than to provide some belated reassurance that the systems are now robust (or will be made so), and that the ‘cultural’ issues are being tackled. When historically I have tried to get clarity from MOJ / HMCTS about how they handle data breaches relating to anonymisation errors in published judgments, the responses have been less than clear or reassuring – I was never able to establish that any such breaches had been logged internally or self reported to the ICO by HMCTS, even where they were the responsibility of HMCTS staff rather than individual judges (to whom exemptions in relation to data protection apply). There is no reference to the ICO in the BBC article, and I don’t know what approach has been or is being taken to those issues either by HMCTS or the ICO. But I would be very interested in finding out.

Radio silence

There is stuff going on behind the scenes that is taking priority over blogging and what have you. I'll get back to it soon enough, and maybe will write about some of it one day - but for now this is just a note to say I'm prioritising family (Trying for once to practice what I preach). And whilst I'm writing this note, I might as well also mention that I'm now over on Mastodon (@familoo.mas.to). So far I am finding it somewhat overburdened with kittens, content warnings and excruciating courtesy, all of which makes me perversely rather drawn to be mildly ornery - but I dare say I'll find my corner and way of operating within it, and will make my own sort of peace with the new society. (I'm not leaving twitter by the way). TTFN. Back when I have more of a spring in my tail.

read more

An Arbitration in a Case Concerning Children

This is a guest post by Nick Marston. Nick is a family arbitrator at St John’s Chambers, Bristol.   A few weeks ago I conducted an arbitration in a case concerning permission to remove four children permanently from the jurisdiction. Arbitrations involving issues concerning children are not usual in Bristol so I thought it might be interesting to set out some of my impressions after conducting this one.   The Applicant was the mother and the Respondent was the father. I am not going to say any more about the facts of the case save that both parties had cases with strengths and weaknesses and it was understandable that they could not agree and that some form of adjudication after a contested hearing was going to be necessary. It was a case with very big consequences to the parties whatever the outcome, and the children (who were all over 10 yrs old) were being particularly stressed and needed a speedy resolution.   The parties had applied to court at the start of the...

read more

You draft fool

Accuracy matters. Lawyers are supposed to be precise. Contempt of court is serious. It therefore drives me bananas when I see the following at the top of a Children Act order: "The names of the family and the children are not to be disclosed in public without the court’s permission." Really? Really?? Is this what we actually mean to say? That a child who wins a bravery award or a swimming gala or who rescues a cat from up a tree can't be named as a jolly good fellow in their local newspaper just because they happen also to be involved in proceedings? Or a parent cannot post a picture of their child blowing out their birthday candles with the caption 'Happy Birthday to my lovely son Joe Smith' just because they happen also to be involved in proceedings? That a mother cannot publish anything in her own name about any topic at all (say, her new haircut, job or her views on the current Prime Minister) just because she happens also to be involved in proceedings? Clearly that is NOT what...

read more

Instructions to download a Whatsapp chat thread

For various reasons its been challenging to find time to blog lately, but I thought this little how to guide would be quick to pop up, and that it might be of use to family lawyers and litigants who need to produce evidence of exchanges on WhatsApp. It can be very tiresome to have to screenshot and scroll through screeds of material, which increases page count, is difficult to follow and often features duplication or missed bits (intentionally or otherwise). Whilst this method won't retrieve intentionally deleted messages as a phone download by an expert might, it can be useful, particularly where the download of both 'sides' of a chat can be compared to identify if one party has deleted something inconvenient to them, as long as that message is retained on the download of the other party (sometimes a whatsapp message can be deleted for all parties, but as far as I understand it only if that deletion is done almost immediately after sending. Later deletions only seem to have effect...

read more

End of days…

It is a time of changing seasons...the summer is drawing to a blustery, wet end. And everything has changed overnight with the passing of the Queen and the silent passing of the crown to her son, King Charles III. How strange it is to type: King Charles III. I have an odd sense of discombobulation. I don't have a better word for it. Everything is disconnected, out of order. Muddled. That is partly as a result of our national news, but it's broader, and also more personal than that. 700 and something days ago in March 2020 I started, almost accidentally, a 'self-isolation diary' in a series of tweets. It felt like end of days then. I cried with anxiety at bedtime some nights as we were told by the government we were not allowed out of our homes, and food was rationed. Seems a long time ago now, but that tweet thread continued, and little by little the log of my life began to approach something more like 'normal' (whatever that is), in increments, sometimes with a step back, sometimes...

read more

About this blog

“Pink Tape” isn’t just about family law. I post about topics that interest me, which mostly revolve around family law, but also include non-legal family-related topics as well as unrelated subjects. I hope this blog will convince at least one person that not all of us in the legal profession are money-hungry sharks. Some of us are actually quite nice. Additionally, I aim to provide useful information about family law for those working in the field without being too heavy or boring.

The primary goal of the blog is to improve the quality of public information and discussions about legal issues.

I understand that not everyone is a fan of “Pink Tape” or family lawyers in general.

latest

Blog Posts

That Homer moment…

Just like Homer Simpson, we've all had that moment where we have let slip what we really think or someone has heard something that we never intended them to hear. Unlike Homer, most of us can distinguish between our own internal monologue and audible speech, but we do...

An office of one’s own…

It's taken me almost two decades to get my own office. The fact that I now have one I think has shaped my experience of lockdown quite massively - and very much for the better. I've been casting my mind back to my working spaces and practices over the years at the...

running wild

running wild

We've reached that stage in the summer where everything is a bit out of control, like a lanky teenager on a growth spurt, not quite sure how to control his limbs, which are flopping and drooping everywhere you want to walk. The footpaths are narrower, as runners and...

The Family Court in Lockdown – Gresham Panel Discussion

*movie trailer voice* Tonight, on a screen somewhere near you....starring Professor Jo, Cyrus Larizadeh, Louise Tickle....and .....drum roll. *cough* Me. Well, I'm not sure how well we fulfilled our brief, and I think I have the look of a woman whose brain has been...

Forever associated with a giant glass of red…

Oh dear... I've been keeping a daily tweet diary since the start of my pre-lockdown self-isolation some 3 months ago. It's one of those projects you aren't sure why you are doing other than because you started it, and you haven't yet got to the end. The thread isn't...

Invidious

Invidious Adjective : (of an action or situation) likely to arouse or incur resentment or anger in others. (of a comparison or distinction) unfairly discriminating; unjust.   And so it goes... There is a lot about the covid-justice system that is invidious. For...

Glass Half Full

So, lockdown sucks. When this all started I kept crying myself to sleep, spent the night wrestling with anxiety dreams and woke earlier than I ever have (I am a sleeper not an early bird). It felt like the end of days. I was acutely frightened for my family's health...

I’ve got a little job for you…

This is your homework task. It is due in by SUNDAY. Over at The Transparency Project the team have been crazy busy what with finishing a mammoth response to the President's Transparency Review (if there is a prize for the longest I think we've won it), and with a...

Necessity Not Evangelism

I saw a tweet yesterday from Judge Itis (@itisjudge) complaining that Professor Susskind was 'pontificating' in the Financial Times about remote hearings. https://twitter.com/ItisJudge/status/1258735590738219013?s=03 It piqued my interest so much that I went and...

Rules of the blog

Anonymized or fictional

All the information on this blog is anonymized or fictional to avoid causing any trouble for anyone, including myself. I have modified details to prevent the identification of specific cases.

Comments

 I won’t approve comments that, in my judgment, breach privacy laws related to family matters. Unless individuals have been identified in a published judgment, I won’t disclose their involvement in any proceedings.

Nothing Defamatory

 I will not post anything that I believe could be considered defamatory. Due to time constraints, I can’t fact-check every statement in a comment. Therefore, I must be cautious to prevent potential legal issues or threatening letters. If you’re certain that a comment is not defamatory, you can publish it elsewhere at your own risk.

NOT Legal Advice

The content of this blog is not intended to constitute legal advice, so please don’t interpret it as such. It may seem relevant to your situation, but it likely isn’t. I cannot be held responsible for any reliance you place on its contents.

Accuracy

The information on the blog is as accurate and up to date as possible, considering my other commitments. Pink Tape is a hobby that I work on when time allows. Therefore, I can’t cover all legal changes or update information that becomes outdated.

External Links

I cannot be held responsible for the content of external sites linked from this blog, in terms of their accuracy or the opinions expressed on them

Moderation

I’ve implemented comment moderation on this blog to filter out comments that are repeatedly negative or offensive about lawyers. Rest assured, I won’t block sensible contributions, even if they disagree with me. I will strive to moderate promptly, but occasionally a comment may get lost in spam.

Right of Reply

If a post contains an inaccuracy about you and you’d like it corrected, feel free to comment for a right of reply. Please respect that the content on this blog is my intellectual property, and ask for permission before reposting. If you have any topics or blog post suggestions, feel free to email me at familoo@pinktape.co.uk.

Copyright

All material on this site is copyright of Lucy Reed. Please do not reproduce without permission.