Pink Tape

A BLOG FROM THE FAMILY BAR

...in which I ricochet from too serious to too flippant and where I may vent, rant or wax lyrical at my own whim, mostly about family law. Constructive co-ranting welcome. More...

Newsletter

The delicate politics of the automated reply

I’ve changed my out of office three times in the last couple of weeks. One change to say I was so busy that I might take some time to respond (this one offended someone who wasn’t as busy and who presumably thought I was just being a show off and rubbing their nose in it) One change to say I was wearing another hat for a little while and wouldn’t be looking specifically at chambers emails for a bit One more to politely explain to the people who seem to think that by some alchemy the combination of the words URGENT and INJUSTICE and CORRUPTION or BIAS will magically produce free and instantaneous legal advice based upon a long stream of consciousness email without so much as an eyelash at any papers – that in fact such enquiries need to go via my clerks, and anyway I’m too busy to take on such cases. This latter change was prompted by someone who read the first OOO and took it as a sign that they should simply send a second email, this time sprinkling in a few more of the magic words in, insisting it really was so urgent that it practically required them to ignore my OOO. NB If you do this sort of thing you are, in my book, not a suitable candidate for direct instruction of a barrister in any event because you lack boundaries. I also had to block a former client for the first time this week, after an unexpected Whatsapp call at 8.30pm. So, I’m sorry if it offends anyone, but I’m not going to apologise for being busy and I’m doubling down on the OOO for my own sanity. People who feel entitled to our time and expertise because of how special their case is or how important their issue is invariably never mention payment. That includes genuinely desperate parents who feel they have nowhere else to turn, and it includes professionals who should know better (like the journalist from a major broadcast organisation who cold called for a ‘quick chat’ recently and didn’t seem to understand that barristers don’t and can’t give legal advice about specific cases without a) proper instructions b) seeing some papers c) payment (even after I had spelled out the limitations of what I could say in the course of a cold call). I do work for free, but I am far more likely to be offer to work for free in response to an enquiry that acknowledges an inability to pay, which provides a simple explanation of the problem, and which is presented as a request rather than a demand. I get a lot of these emails and calls, many of them the result of the limitations on legal aid, or long running proceedings that have exhausted people’s funds – and I do try to respond, to say I’m sorry but I’m already committed on that date, I can’t give legal advice by email or by phone (as applicable) etc… I try to signpost, to give general information when I can, to explain how legal aid works when KCs are involved – and very, very occasionally I accept an instruction. I do all this rather than just letting the clerks deal with it because I know that each person that contacts me is in pain and that they are often confused and alone. But there is a significant rump of enquiries that are not just unsolicited, but which are also entitled, often over-confident in their own assertion of obvious injustice, which disclose a significant history of simply refusing to accept the outcome of a decisions and actions long past, and which are expecting something for free and demanding it now. And who keep on sending more and more emails in the hope I will relent. Or who get cross with me when I politely explain it doesn’t work that way. To those people: I know you found me on the internet and you think I am just the person to help – the only person who can help (this is what you always say but you often forward me copies of emails you have sent to lots of other people beforehand) – but newsflash: I am not a superhero. I’m a mum with a family, and a job, and with clients who I have commitments to that have deadlines and standards. I don’t have a time machine or magic wand. I’m just one lawyer. And although my job is a vocation for me, it is also the way I pay my mortgage. And if you are unable to respect my boundaries and bombard me with long emails then I will almost certainly not accept you as a direct access client even if I have capacity*. It sometimes feels as if the more of yourself you give for free (to charities, to committees, to pro bono legal advice and representation), and the harder you work – the more people demand and expect of you. It’s really, really hard to maintain boundaries in this job at the best of times, and a bit of self protection is sometimes essential. An OOO is a pretty flimsy protection, but sometimes its all we have. Of course barristers are famously always wanging on about how busy they are even if they aren’t, and it feels a bit stroppy and puffed up to even be complaining about all this. But the truth is a lot of us are perpetually struggling to keep up most of the time, because barrister’s diaries are very difficult to keep in balance. And I don’t think we should discourage people from saying ‘Woah. I have a lot on. I’m drawing a line’. Personally, I’ve had a belly full of being grumbled at this month. In court, out of court, by people I know, by people who should know better, by people I have never met, from people I have tried to help and people who just expect me to drop everything and solve their problem. So: take my word for it, there is a good reason for my OOO. And it isn’t always just about your feelings. It’s also about my boundaries. Top tip: if you don’t like my OOO, you can always stop emailing me.   *(for the avoidance of doubt the cab rank rule doesn’t apply to this sort of work, and in my judgment it only compatible with practice at the bar and the level of service I like to provide for a small proportion of cases / clients. I am selective about direct access clients for my own sake and theirs. The vast majority of the people who contact me would be better served by instructing of a solicitor in the first instance, and if that solicitor then wishes to instruct me the cab rank rule applies and I follow it scrupulously).

Recipe for the Perfect CPD Plan

Before I embark on making turkey risotto (we have passed through the turkey curry, turkey sandwich and turkey stock phases, only skipping the turkey pie phase because I can't be bothered to make any pastry), I thought I would share my recipe for a great New Year's CPD plan with you. Some of us view food simply as fuel, whilst others see its potential to create happiness. A good CPD plan should be more than just fuel, box ticking, or compliance. It should feed your enthusiasm for the job and give you a balance of everything you need for the year ahead. If you are one of those lawyers who is happy doing the bare minimum at the 11th hour, you are probably sitting through some very boring CPD videos and doing some tick box quiz whilst crying into your baileys. It doesn't have to be like this. Now that CPD plans have been deregulated you can basically put in anything you like, which is my kind of cooking - but a good recipe always retains some basic structure and balance. There are five...

read more

Questions about hearings IRL

I've done a smattering of in-person hearings recently, though only one with live witnesses. In the course of that hearing one party was told off for using a mobile phone in the courtroom (not during evidence, I hasten to add). That party had been checking for an email relating to the evidence being given, something the might also have done on a laptop or tablet, had they had one in court for the purposes of taking a note. Certainly, such devices are now commonplace in courtrooms, at least on the part of lawyers if not lay parties. And, as is also now commonplace, within a minute of the judge having explained phones weren't allowed in court now we were back in person, we all had to consult those phones in order to check our diaries to set the next hearing date. Of course these sorts of contradictions existed before covid, but the rules of engagement are even less clear now than they were before. Most judges know we could not have got through the last two years without liberal use of...

read more

Griffiths v Tickle – a lawyer’s view

Most of the newspapers carried the story on Saturday: 'Andrew Griffiths found to have raped his wife'. I represented the applicant journalist, Louise Tickle, in both the High Court and, when the father appealed, in the Court of Appeal. It took Louise and Brian Farmer (Press Association) over a year to be able to write those stories. I was involved for about six months of that period, and Tortoise also backed Louise's application, because they saw just how important it was to pursue. You can read the judgments at first instance, in the High Court (Tickle v Griffiths [2021] EWHC 3365 (Fam)) and from the Court of Appeal (Griffiths v Tickle [2021] EWCA Civ 1882) here. This post is an explanation of the process and the law that we had to navigate to get the judgment containing the findings of rape and abuse published, and in particular to get it published with names of both Kate and Andrew Griffiths left in. Most of the responses I've seen to the publication of the judgment are supportive...

read more

Fighting the good fight

The estimable Bob was musing on twitter the other day, about lawyers who talk about fighting in court : https://twitter.com/OnlyDads/status/1464127125712248835 Just in case that tweet doesn't embed properly (I really should update my site, I know) his tweet said this : "Saw a tweet yesterday from a family law professional talking about returning from court after a "fight". The What about Henry training confirms the biggest problem for children in the context of divorce/separation is parental conflict. It should never be about a "fight"." Who could argue with that eminently sensible proposition? You know the answer. A lawyer could argue with that. And so I did. Politely, and in a non-fighty sort of way. Because actually, whilst I agree with the sentiment behind that tweet - minimising conflict and discouraging a 'fight' mindset in clients is a good thing - I'm not sure it is *quite* the whole picture. Wise Bob also said (again, rightly) that twitter isn't the best place for...

read more

While you’re at it, boss…

In The Transparency Review the President says he is going to amend PD12G so that 'Accredited media representatives and legal bloggers should be added to the list of those to whom a party may communicate information relating to children proceedings under FPR r12.75 (1), PD12G and PD14E.' That's good news, but in truth there is a lot more wrong with PD12G than suggested by this simple 'fix'. Actually, let me frame that more positively - PD12G could be made much better than it is. It's got a long history. Once upon a time the tables in PD12G were a part of the main rules. Eventually it's tabulated list of people and purposes became too cumbersome to manage and it was hived off into a PD, and every so often it's terms are expanded to capture something that it has become obvious should be permissible, but actually isn't. Usually something that has been happening for years inadvertently or blatantly with various people turning a blind eye. Going even further back, the precursor to rule...

read more

About this blog

“Pink Tape” isn’t just about family law. I post about topics that interest me, which mostly revolve around family law, but also include non-legal family-related topics as well as unrelated subjects. I hope this blog will convince at least one person that not all of us in the legal profession are money-hungry sharks. Some of us are actually quite nice. Additionally, I aim to provide useful information about family law for those working in the field without being too heavy or boring.

The primary goal of the blog is to improve the quality of public information and discussions about legal issues.

I understand that not everyone is a fan of “Pink Tape” or family lawyers in general.

latest

Blog Posts

Finding our families

Finding our families

Some thoughts, based on the experience of someone I love : about the irrepressible drive to find out who we are, and how technology and our increasing connectedness make it possible to find family connections where once there would have been a dead end. A DNA test kit...

The recipe for wellbeing

The recipe for wellbeing

There has been a lot of baking going on in our house this summer, thanks to the kids version of bake off. Even 9, who survives on approximately seven simple foodstuffs (cheese, ketchup, noodles, pasta, marmite, pizza (cheese flavour) and cake (preferably lemon...

Sunday homework club

Sunday homework club

It's not normal, is it? But every lawyer knows exactly what #sundayhomeworkclub is. And by god are we skilled at self-distraction tactics to avoid the inevitable. This blog post. Case in point... In fact, I've had a fair few weekends lately that have involved no...

What have you done to my red book, dudes?

Since I started life at the bar a copy of the Red Book (Family Court Practice) has been my comfort blanket. Initially an old beaten copy of last year's edition given to me by someone in chambers who knew how tough it was to find the money to buy one when starting out...

Pass the bundle…

Pass the bundle…

So, a few months ago there was a flurry of notices about the collection of bundles at the end of court hearings, with stern warnings about who would be reported to the ICO for GDPR breaches if the right person didn't take responsibility for the right bundle at the...

The sanctity of the advocates room

A twitter thread was kicked off by Jack Harrison yesterday, complaining about the encroachment into advocates rooms of guardians and social workers.... https://twitter.com/JackHarrison/status/1148523237518786566 My initial reaction was 'Hell yes! What Jack said!'...

A professional discourtesy

A professional discourtesy

We lawyers are odd creatures, where superficially polite language can conceal the most cutting of understated insults. Viz, 'with respect' denotes anything but. Rarely does a lawyer engage in a direct insult or criticism. Such is the dance that we dance, out of...

Problem exists between chair and keyboard

Problem exists between chair and keyboard

If you ever hear the IT support guys mention 'PEBCAK' you know it's time to brush up on your IT skills. My husband, charming soul that he is, often diagnoses PEBCAK. To be fair, he's usually right. But we all have our PEBCAK moments...   A little over a year ago...

Too boring even for you…

Too boring even for you…

Nothing is too boring for a lawyer... we are language-geeks of the highest order who thrive on complexity. Family lawyers of course are a funny breed, we bury our law deep beneath human emotion and the messiness of dysfunctional and broken relationships, and thrive...

Rules of the blog

Anonymized or fictional

All the information on this blog is anonymized or fictional to avoid causing any trouble for anyone, including myself. I have modified details to prevent the identification of specific cases.

Comments

 I won’t approve comments that, in my judgment, breach privacy laws related to family matters. Unless individuals have been identified in a published judgment, I won’t disclose their involvement in any proceedings.

Nothing Defamatory

 I will not post anything that I believe could be considered defamatory. Due to time constraints, I can’t fact-check every statement in a comment. Therefore, I must be cautious to prevent potential legal issues or threatening letters. If you’re certain that a comment is not defamatory, you can publish it elsewhere at your own risk.

NOT Legal Advice

The content of this blog is not intended to constitute legal advice, so please don’t interpret it as such. It may seem relevant to your situation, but it likely isn’t. I cannot be held responsible for any reliance you place on its contents.

Accuracy

The information on the blog is as accurate and up to date as possible, considering my other commitments. Pink Tape is a hobby that I work on when time allows. Therefore, I can’t cover all legal changes or update information that becomes outdated.

External Links

I cannot be held responsible for the content of external sites linked from this blog, in terms of their accuracy or the opinions expressed on them

Moderation

I’ve implemented comment moderation on this blog to filter out comments that are repeatedly negative or offensive about lawyers. Rest assured, I won’t block sensible contributions, even if they disagree with me. I will strive to moderate promptly, but occasionally a comment may get lost in spam.

Right of Reply

If a post contains an inaccuracy about you and you’d like it corrected, feel free to comment for a right of reply. Please respect that the content on this blog is my intellectual property, and ask for permission before reposting. If you have any topics or blog post suggestions, feel free to email me at familoo@pinktape.co.uk.

Copyright

All material on this site is copyright of Lucy Reed. Please do not reproduce without permission.