The small matter of fees
It is unlikely that all services will be fully resolved in the short-term. As such we are now refining further plans for contingency,in the event that the need for contingency continues beyond this month. We will work closely with representative bodies to ensure this supports providers and their clients to the maximum extent.
We willmaintain our focus on ensuring access to justice, and that providers canbe confident in their payment for work done.
Brilliant. As the extract above notes, there is a ‘contingency scheme’, apparently soon to be ‘refined’. But as it stands, this scheme invites participants to accept payment of a weekly loan equating to 25% of an essentially arbitrary figure (calculated from the amount we received in the 3 months prior to the hack, which given the lumpiness of most of our incomes is truly meaningless), which might be called back in within 2 weeks of the system being back online, at a time when presumably the LAA will have a massive, humungous and ginormous (etc) mountainous backlog of claims to process, with elongated payment times as a result. The process of reconciling the amounts paid against the claims once they come in is likely to be nightmarish. We don’t even receive a remittance for the contingency payments so it is easy to see there will be all sorts of antics and problems with this. So for now it’s a choice between frying pan or fire (the third route is eyewateringly expensive commercial debt loans which I know some colleagues have preferred, which tells you something). Either way, the risk – and cost – is entirely on us. Don’t claim and risk not being able to pay our tax bills, mortgages etc. Or claim and risk being unable to pay them later because you are caught up in the backlog and / or in an interminable tangle of reconciliation and recoupment… or pay high rates of interest as a result of our default … but obviously, do please keep on working without complaint even thought we can’t give you any guarantees about payment at all. They didn’t actually say that out loud, but that is presumably what this coded message is intended to mean: We willmaintain our focus on ensuring access to justice, and that providers canbe confident in their payment for work done. Are you confident? What other industry would have people working on a ‘we’ll pay you when we can if that’s ok’ basis? And a ‘we’ll borrow you some money and claim it back when we feel like it too’ basis? That isn’t even the worst of it. If and when we ever do get paid it’ll be at rates that haven’t been increased for over two decades. And while we wait for a solution, you can be sure that another arm of the government, HMRC will be ruthlessly efficient in expecting us to pay tax promptly even as our income stream has dried up entirely, apparently unable to appreciate that life at the bar is an unbreakable cycle of robbing Peter (Peter being the savings you have diligently put by for tax) to pay Paul (Paul being your mortgage, which you can’t pay because your aged debt with the LAA keeps getting bigger but nothing is coming out the other end). I’m not especially grumbling on my own behalf, though it is somewhat anxiety inducing and is making it very difficult to plan things – holidays and home maintenance projects depend on being able to project your likely income – always difficult at the bar, but now utterly impossible. No, I’m thinking more of the junior end of the bar, those who have been on maternity or off sick and need to get earning, and those who were planning a retirement soon, for whom this will cause very real problems. Anyone who doesn’t have a stash of savings or a private client practice to cushion them in forthcoming months is going to have to continually weigh up the risks of opting in to the contingency scheme or not. I’m pleased that the FLBA and Bar Council are working really hard on behalf of all of us to encourage the LAA to sort out the mess, and I dare say the contingency scheme existing at all is largely down to their swift response – but the reality is that this sort of IT problem can’t be resolved quickly and the current contingency arrangements are not hugely reassuring or satisfactory for many. There are hints in the LAA emails of ‘further plans’ if the outage goes on much longer, but what those might be is anyone’s guess. Something that places the risk and additional costs in the lap of the party who is unable to meet their obligation to pay for services rendered would be a good start. Anyway, I’m off to get an early night before another week of undertaking a legal aid trial, some of it away from home. Which I might get paid for in 2026, if I’m lucky, Perhaps the hotel and train company I’ll be using to get there and stay there won’t mind if I offer to pay for my room and ticket at some unspecified later date?Podcasts
Lately, I've been listening to podcasts in the shower. I don't like headphones and I don't have a daily commute to speak of so when else am I going to listen to them, right? Plus, Radio 4 has become almost unbearable and I have to listen to something to wake myself up. Due to a combination of poor acoustics and ventilation I listen to said podcasts with the tiny top window wide open and the bluetooth radio on full volume. My husband has only recently thought to tell me that when I do this I broadcast every word of my chosen podcast from the second floor across all the gardens in the neighbourhood. I like to think therefore that the standards of public legal education in my part of North Somerset are particularly high. Saying that, I did try and listen to one such podcast whilst gardening recently, and every time I switched it on the neighbour remembered something else he'd forgotten to strim. So, perhaps not. Anyway, what delights have I been forcing my neighbours to endure? Well,...
The portal of doom cometh…
I've had my first taste of the new public law case management portal this week. By a process of trial, error, clicking, clicking, unfurling and furling, clicking, scrolling and yet more clicking - I have established that this is in fact an inter-dimensional portal into a parallel universe where logic does not apply, and where the three click rule has been inverted so that every action requires a minimum of 3 clicks, and every fifth action opens a new browser window, just for larks. I'm sure it will improve with user feedback, but it is fair to say that my first journey around a case in portal world left me feeling a bit like the girl with a crush on Morten Harket in that 'Take On Me' video... (yes, yes we all had a crush on Morten Harket. I mean the girl who is taken by the hand and inside the comic book through a bright white maze of confusion). Sadly, I did not find Morten Harket. I did manage to upload a case outline. I'm not sure I put it in the right place or that anyone will...
Choose your words with care, listen as if with someone else’s ears…
I want to talk about language. About the gap between how it's meant and how it’s received. About what happens when our words are heard by someone standing in a different place to us, and who is wearing very different shoes. ‘Wrongful’ News stories about parents who are suspected of hurting their babies but who are later exonerated often use words like 'wrongly' or 'falsely' accused. That language, I know, is the language of the parents, although perhaps it suits the purposes of the media too. But I've noticed that by the time 'wrongly' or 'falsely' reaches the ears and eyes of those who are part of the system, it is often received as a direct, personal criticism of individuals as much as it is a way of describing the parents' experience. Whilst some of these exonerated parents are aggrieved at their treatment by individuals, others are merely describing what the child protection system has done to them - they are describing that, whilst the outcome was (eventually) right, the process...
When Crime and Family Collide
This is an interesting judgment. The facts of it are very sad (vulnerable, isolated teenaged brother and sister who somehow manage to end up as mother and father of a baby at the age of 14) - but I'm more interested in the bells it rings regarding the interplay between family and criminal process : Y (disclosure to MPS) [2021] EWFC B33. As is usual for HHJ Atkinson the judgment is well crafted, thorough and poignant. It is not obvious at the outset just how cross she is, but by the end you certainly know it, even though she remains fair and polite throughout. Because what happened in this case is something I've seen happen in a number of my own, and to me it feels like HHJ Atkinson is highlighting something that may be happening more widely : Firstly, the police and / or CPS seem to be waiting for a decision in the care proceedings or disclosure from them before making a charging decision - sometimes the police just won't send the case for a charging decision until any application...
From a place of purity…
I've been wrestling with a couple of blog posts to post here for a while. They are stuck. I am snorkling through metaphysical, ethical, topical treacle with them. They may never be published. Luckily for you. But this. This comes from a place of passion and purity and will write itself in a jiffy. And I will feel purified for getting it off my chest. Which I really need to do. The damned templates. I spent a long time today wrestling with templates. Time I don't have and I don't care to waste on inconsequential irritants. Perhaps I should just submit my draft orders full of hanging brackets] and slashes / and occasional words in red or green. But quite apart from the twitching it induces, I like to think I'm vaguely professional. I had hoped when I saw yet another iteration of the helpful templates that this time they would have taken heed of years of us griping about the awful, wretched formatting and would have spared a few minutes to sort it out. Before promulgating it to the...
About this blog
“Pink Tape” isn’t just about family law. I post about topics that interest me, which mostly revolve around family law, but also include non-legal family-related topics as well as unrelated subjects. I hope this blog will convince at least one person that not all of us in the legal profession are money-hungry sharks. Some of us are actually quite nice. Additionally, I aim to provide useful information about family law for those working in the field without being too heavy or boring.
The primary goal of the blog is to improve the quality of public information and discussions about legal issues.
I understand that not everyone is a fan of “Pink Tape” or family lawyers in general.
latest
Blog Posts
Book Review : Transparency in the Family Courts: Publicity and Privacy in Practice
This is a review by Rodney Noon of a book co-written by myself, Julie Doughty and Paul Magrath. It originally appeared in Nagalro's Seen & Heard (Vol 29, Issue 1, 2019) and is reproduced with kind permission. When selecting books for review, it has been my...
A view from the coalface
I've been getting blank faces whenever I've asked colleagues what they think of the latest 'President's View' (the first from this reincarnation of the President, Lord Justice Macfarlane). Turns out that was because nobody has had time to read Family Law journal and...
Why do lawyers talk legalese?
I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately. Last week I went to record an episode of Word of Mouth with Michael Rosen all about legal language (airing later today – Tues 22nd– at 4pm on Radio 4), so I want to set down some of the thoughts I’ve had along the way. As it...
Journalists and legal bloggers attending family courts – A Workshop for lawyers
29 January 2019 5.30pm, Gresham College, London Next week I'll be running this Transparency Project training workshop for lawyers. Please do come if you can. More information: In light of the Legal Blogging Pilot implemented through PD36J, The Transparency Project are...
What’s in a judgment anyway?
In November a journalist I know and respect took to social media to air her concerns about the probity of family court process as regards transcripts of hearings. She did so in good faith based upon ‘authoritative’ information she had been given about a tricky topic....
No more apologies
Gosh, it's been eons since I've made space for poor old Pink Tape. But I'm not apologising. This year I seem to have spent most of my time neglecting Pink Tape or apologising for neglecting it and promising I'll try harder. But I'm not going to try harder. I WANT to...
Covert Recording
Last night was the Annual Family Justice Council Debate - and this year the topic was covert recording. The motion was 'nothing to hide - what's wrong with covert recording?' Hannah Markham QC and I were allocated to the 'pro' side of the debate, and HHJ Lazarus and...
The many uses of Pink Tape…
This afternoon, in an interstitial moment of madness brought on by having become unaccustomed to having an actual weekend involving anything apart from paperwork, I have been engaging in impromptu and not altogether successful attempts to make Christmas decorations...
‘Nothing to hide – what’s wrong with covert recordings?’
The Family Justice Council run a debate every December and it is usually excellent. Notwithstanding the fact that this year the line up will involve yours truly it should still be an interesting event to attend - the other panellists are the excellent Hannah Markham...
Rules of the blog
Anonymized or fictional
All the information on this blog is anonymized or fictional to avoid causing any trouble for anyone, including myself. I have modified details to prevent the identification of specific cases.
Comments
I won’t approve comments that, in my judgment, breach privacy laws related to family matters. Unless individuals have been identified in a published judgment, I won’t disclose their involvement in any proceedings.
Nothing Defamatory
I will not post anything that I believe could be considered defamatory. Due to time constraints, I can’t fact-check every statement in a comment. Therefore, I must be cautious to prevent potential legal issues or threatening letters. If you’re certain that a comment is not defamatory, you can publish it elsewhere at your own risk.
NOT Legal Advice
The content of this blog is not intended to constitute legal advice, so please don’t interpret it as such. It may seem relevant to your situation, but it likely isn’t. I cannot be held responsible for any reliance you place on its contents.
Accuracy
The information on the blog is as accurate and up to date as possible, considering my other commitments. Pink Tape is a hobby that I work on when time allows. Therefore, I can’t cover all legal changes or update information that becomes outdated.
External Links
I cannot be held responsible for the content of external sites linked from this blog, in terms of their accuracy or the opinions expressed on them
Moderation
I’ve implemented comment moderation on this blog to filter out comments that are repeatedly negative or offensive about lawyers. Rest assured, I won’t block sensible contributions, even if they disagree with me. I will strive to moderate promptly, but occasionally a comment may get lost in spam.
Right of Reply
If a post contains an inaccuracy about you and you’d like it corrected, feel free to comment for a right of reply. Please respect that the content on this blog is my intellectual property, and ask for permission before reposting. If you have any topics or blog post suggestions, feel free to email me at familoo@pinktape.co.uk.
Copyright
All material on this site is copyright of Lucy Reed. Please do not reproduce without permission.





