Mea Culpa – a rather belated clarification
20.2 Orders for interim remedies (1) The court may grant the following interim remedies – (a) an interim injunction; (b) an interim declaration; (c) an order – (i) for the detention, custody or preservation of relevant property; (ii) for the inspection of relevant property;So, what did I actually say?
The Family Court itself has no obvious realistic mechanism at its disposal to seize, download and analyse the contents of a digital device such as a smartphone in the absence of a criminal investigation in the course of which the police decide to (and are able to) secure a device for download. The Family Court’s powers are simply powers of disclosure of material already obtained by the police…That first bit isn’t quite right. It muddles ‘realistic mechanisms’ and powers. I went on:
…although the High Court has a power to order seizure of a device or records, there would inevitably all sorts of logistical problems with securing orders before data was destroyed or ‘lost’, identifying the person responsible for seizure of the device and persuading the legal aid agency to fund the download and analysis of the data. Realistically this is unachievable – if the police haven’t already done the legwork it ain’t gonna happen. And in most private law cases the legal aid rates are already unsustainably low (they are far lower than care cases), making the idea of an advocate trawling through tens of thousands of pages on the off chance for no fee very unappealing – and arguably even more unattractive for a privately paying client. Even in care cases there is no fee for this work, but the hearing fees are less awful than in private law cases.In my defence, I *think* I was talking about logistics as much as law, and may have had in mind private law proceedings where the practicalities and funding constraints applicable usually mean that what is theoretically possible is not achievable in practice – or perhaps even that this is rarely achievable for anyone except the local authority in public law proceedings (because usually such an application requires the provision of replacement phones, which only the LA has funding to be able to provide). But if that was what I thought, I didn’t express it clearly. It is also possible, given the reference to the High Court, that I (wrongly) thought only a s9 had the power to do this, and the process of getting a case before a s9 might tip off or allow time for destruction or disposal of evidence. I suppose, being kind to myself, that I would not have been the only lawyer not to have been fully on top of the full scope and boundaries of the powers of the Family Court before Re K in 2024, and I rather suspect that the practice was probably that only a s9 judge would have dealt with a seizure application. Trying to put myself back to 2019 (before covid so in that era where many judges and lawyers were still paper based), I think it was relatively unusual for phone data to be obtained as a result of a family court directing someone to give up their phone, rather than by consent or by means of seizure and onward disclosure by the police. It was also a period where the volume of phone download data was vastly increasing, and doing so faster than people’s IT skills or hard drives could manage, and none of this work was paid (that bit really hasn’t changed, it’s just got worse). It just all seemed a bit of an unmanageable mess. Past me did wisely caveat what I had written with this:
“Below follows a blog post I wrote on the train back from a trial in Plymouth, highly stressed, badly fed and sleep deprived. It may be a little jumbled but I wanted to get it out before the moment passes, and I don’t have the time or energy to polish it, so please be forgiving…”I clearly felt I needed to get it off my chest. I probably should have had a good night’s sleep instead. Now six years later, having just pontificated about owning your mistakes in my most recent post (and having spent a decade banging on about transparency), I feel compelled to get my error off my chest. I suppose this is also an excellent opportunity to remind any readers that none of my blog posts are intended to contain legal advice. But insofar as they contain useful information I do like to try and make sure they are accurate and not misleading. So, here you are, mea culpa. You can read the original blog post here. Or maybe just read FPR 20 and Re K.
Police Disclosure into Family Court cases – including sometimes phone and device downloads
Finding the head space
I don't know about you, but it's hard to find the head space to stop and think and really process life. Each day is about ticking off the things that have a deadline, that must be done by tomorrow or next week - or yesterday. And by the time the 'must-do's are done, I can't summon up the energy for the important but not-time-limited rest. And so it is that this blog has been even more fallow than normal. A serious case of can't be arsed, I'm afraid. But I do have things on my mind, things I want to write about, things that matter. They are just swirling in a cotton wool cloud in my brain, tangled and confused, disordered, intangible, messy. That ambivalence and confusion is how I find myself feeling at the idea we will be going back to face to face hearings soon. Isn't this what we've been waiting for? In fact I find myself very conflicted. The ever smaller sphere of life has its advantages for some of us - I have quite liked being able to work from home, and in some respects to...
Postcard from the blue room…
I'm still here. Hanging on by by fingernails. Or by my ningersnails, as 12 used to cutely say when he was a wee mite. Been v busy and have stuff coming up. Itching to write a proper blog post. Here's one thing I've been busy with. Me and my transparency compadres wrote a thing calling for reform of s12 Administration Act 1960 (that's the thing that stops publication of information about family proceedings). You can read it here. Also keeping me busy is this (giving oral evidence to the President's Transparency review). Yikes. And the Family Justice Council conference on Tuesday. And the last one of the Bath Publishing webinars on Thursday. I may need to enrol on some sort of knowing when to say no training course...except I don't have time.
Redaction Whoopsies
I was prompted by a judgment published last week to write about redaction errors. Before I tell you why, let me just explain the term redaction - lawyers will be familiar with it but it's one of those words that is not always familiar to those in other walks of life. Interestingly, I've discovered a surprising variation in definitions of redaction online, but for our purposes, redaction is the process of removing those bits of information which need to remain confidential when preparing a document for disclosure or publication. It differs from anonymisation or editing because pseudonyms aren't used, and the text isn't written but a place marker is left so that the reader can see something has been removed. Sometimes a short description of what has gone is inserted in [brackets] to help the reader make sense of what is left. The Information Commissioner's Office describes it like this : Redaction is the separation of disclosable from nondisclosable information by blocking out...
Open Justice Webinar Series
I took part in the first of four open justice themed panel discussions last week ('Law, Justice and the Spaces in Between'). This first webinar asked : "Does being watched change how justice is done?" and looked at the role and function of observers in trials, inquests, family courts and tribunals. It was a really interesting discussion, ranging across not only family courts but inquests and other fora. It brought together journalists, participants, lawyers, bloggers and tweeters - and I hope was interesting to the 150 odd people who attended. Part 2 is next week. If you would like to watch a recording of the webinar you can watch here. Details of the rest of the series are in my blog post here.
Not my area…
Money lawyers may dismiss what follows as the deranged ramblings of a mere children lawyer, who rightly gave up money work as 'too hard' - but hear me out... I spent a large chunk of last week listening to - and live tweeting - the conjoined domestic abuse appeals heard by the Court of Appeal on Tues-Thurs. Now this is not the first time I've thought about the implications of domestic abuse across the broader spectrum of Family Court work and beyond my little niche, but it has given rise to some musings about where we are at in terms of their impact on financial remedy specifically. These are not fully thought through proposals or anything, just some queries I'm throwing out for discussion. I think we maybe need to ask ourselves some questions, though I don't profess to have all the answers. It's been a while since I've done financial remedy work, and I may be out of touch. So, things like PD3AA on vulnerable witnesses ostensibly applies to all types of family proceedings where there...
About this blog
“Pink Tape” isn’t just about family law. I post about topics that interest me, which mostly revolve around family law, but also include non-legal family-related topics as well as unrelated subjects. I hope this blog will convince at least one person that not all of us in the legal profession are money-hungry sharks. Some of us are actually quite nice. Additionally, I aim to provide useful information about family law for those working in the field without being too heavy or boring.
The primary goal of the blog is to improve the quality of public information and discussions about legal issues.
I understand that not everyone is a fan of “Pink Tape” or family lawyers in general.
latest
Blog Posts
Do you want the good news or the bad news first?
I'm going to give you the good news. Because it IS good news, and I thank the powers that be for sorting it out. Here it is : HMCTS have formally launched a pilot to fast track lawyers through court security so that we can all arrive at court earlier and in a less...
End of an era
Yesterday Sir James Munby retired. Also, it was my birthday this week. I am old. Not as old as Sir James, but old nonetheless. Also, it was Pink Tape’s birthday this month. She is 11 years old. For a good chunk of Pink Tape’s life (since 2013) I have been writing and...
This is your pilot speaking…brace for impact
There is a new pilot scheme running, which allows parents in certain court areas (including my own) to submit their applications for a Child Arrangements Order (form C100) in an online format. It is only open to parent who are in dispute about child arrangements where...
Zoe’s cross examination of the secret barrister…
Zoe Saunders (@zasaunders) kindly reviewed the Secret Barrister's book for Pink Tape recently. Now she's only gone and managed to get an interview with SB him/herself. Before you all rush to press Zoe for the name and gender of SB, I am reliably informed that Zoe...
My work life imbalance and the big gorgeous eyes
It's ironic that some weeks after the publication of the Bar Council's Working Lives Survey I've only just managed to scrape together enough time to knock up a blog post to say 'Damn Right we're stressed and overworked!'... I'd have written it last weekend but I was...
The Secret Barrister Stories of the Law and How It’s Broken – a family barrister’s perspective.
This is a guest post by barrister Zoe Saunders. Zoe tweets as @ZASaunders. Unless you have been living under a rock you will have noticed that the Criminal Bar are on strike over yet further cuts to their already inadequate pay. You may also have noticed that...
Got Data Protection Rage (GDPR)
No. I won't be sending you a stupid GDPR email. No. I won't be sending you a stupid GDPR email even though you have not heard from me for over a decade and are pretty sure you never bought anything from me in the first place. No. I won't be sending you several...
Left in the lurch
Last week District Judge Read (no relation) published a shocking judgment. I have been thinking about it a lot, waiting for enough quiet time to write down my thoughts about it. I am very bothered by it. The judgment is here : JY v RY [2018] EWFC B16 (27 April 2018)....
Transparency in the Family Courts: Publicity and Privacy in Practice
Today seems like a good day to give you a little preview of my forthcoming book, written with Julie Doughty and Paul Magrath - the rather lovely Foreword written by Sir Andrew McFarlane, soon to be President of the Family Division (congratulations!). Here is what he...
Rules of the blog
Anonymized or fictional
All the information on this blog is anonymized or fictional to avoid causing any trouble for anyone, including myself. I have modified details to prevent the identification of specific cases.
Comments
I won’t approve comments that, in my judgment, breach privacy laws related to family matters. Unless individuals have been identified in a published judgment, I won’t disclose their involvement in any proceedings.
Nothing Defamatory
I will not post anything that I believe could be considered defamatory. Due to time constraints, I can’t fact-check every statement in a comment. Therefore, I must be cautious to prevent potential legal issues or threatening letters. If you’re certain that a comment is not defamatory, you can publish it elsewhere at your own risk.
NOT Legal Advice
The content of this blog is not intended to constitute legal advice, so please don’t interpret it as such. It may seem relevant to your situation, but it likely isn’t. I cannot be held responsible for any reliance you place on its contents.
Accuracy
The information on the blog is as accurate and up to date as possible, considering my other commitments. Pink Tape is a hobby that I work on when time allows. Therefore, I can’t cover all legal changes or update information that becomes outdated.
External Links
I cannot be held responsible for the content of external sites linked from this blog, in terms of their accuracy or the opinions expressed on them
Moderation
I’ve implemented comment moderation on this blog to filter out comments that are repeatedly negative or offensive about lawyers. Rest assured, I won’t block sensible contributions, even if they disagree with me. I will strive to moderate promptly, but occasionally a comment may get lost in spam.
Right of Reply
If a post contains an inaccuracy about you and you’d like it corrected, feel free to comment for a right of reply. Please respect that the content on this blog is my intellectual property, and ask for permission before reposting. If you have any topics or blog post suggestions, feel free to email me at familoo@pinktape.co.uk.
Copyright
All material on this site is copyright of Lucy Reed. Please do not reproduce without permission.



