Wading through the Grey Goo
Prince Charles (as he then was) once popularised the phrase ‘grey goo’ (Explained and Americanised by Wikipedia as ‘gray goo’). He wasn’t actually talking about AI but about nanobots. AI was merely a twinkle in a tech-bro’s eye at that point, but it sometimes it feels apt to describe the waves of samey AI junk we are all wading through, like so much verbal treacle.
A colleague sent me this interesting looking article on the increasing use of AI in US Courts by pro selitigants (that’s litigants in person or people without lawyers to UK lawyers and normal humans respectively):
Access to Justice in the Age of AI:Evidence from U.S. Federal Courts
I confess, because screens, the internet and social media have rotted my brain and destroyed my concentration span*, I haven’t read it in full, but it is on my ‘read it properly soon’ reading list, and it chimes with what I think we are all seeing on the ground in our own practices over here. The immediate response from colleagues who were cc’d was that they are definitely seeing a proliferation of obviously or apparently AI generated materials from litigants in person – and also sometimes from lawyers. This of course is not news, but the pace of change and the early signs of its real life impact on efficiency and justice is alarming.
Yes of course, AI is here to stay and it is sometimes (maybe often) helpful. But not always. And I am increasingly worried that when it is weilded by those without legal understanding, without an appreciation of its limitation of AI, and without an understanding of the expectations around AI use, or the risks and potential consequences of inappropriate use of AI or of reliance on its unhelpful output – it is not a force for good. I worry that rather than increasing access to justice it will create only an illusion of this, but in fact will generate worse outcomes for litigants and will generally increase the pressure and workload under which our justice system and our judges are already labouring. That’s the grey goo. Clogging up the system.
Statistics from Cafcass for the year to date (up to end April 26) show a stark and worrying trend over the last year. I’d be happy to bet a Solero** on that trend being, at least in part, derived from AI ‘assisted’ litigants. Of course, since we don’t really do proper statistics in the Family Court we’ll never know and I need never pay out on that bet, but it’s a reasonable hunch I think – at least consistent with the biggest uptick being in categories of case where there are the highest numbers of litigants in person (private law).

Interestingly, those stats are even more marked than the same picture for ytd up to end Mar 26 (no longer on Cafcass website but I happen to have downloaded this last month for a talk). I’m no statistician, but can’t help but notice that was was an 8.2% increase in the number of private law cases in March is now a stonking 15.9%.

What is driving that? What will it mean for case duration and waiting times? If a chunk of these new cases are driven by AI, will it also mean that those cases will be more….treacly? The emergent sense is very much that in many cases AI causes LiPs to produce verbose but ultimately unhelpful material, that consumes time and energy and distracts everyone from the task at hand to nobody’s advantage. It does not bode well.
Of course, it won’t all be AI driven, but I confess I’m not sure what else IS driving such a notable rate of increase of new apps. Could it be cost of living / economic issues? Or an increase in returners coming back to court after an order has failed? (if so, one hopes that does not include families returning to court after being through the Pathfinder process – it would be helpful to know one way or the other). Answers on a postcard please!
In more positive AI related news, this simplified judgment seems like a great use of AI:
Make it simple! Make it clear! Using AI to improve clarity and understanding of a judgment
I know from experience that when it comes to simplifying documents for those who need an easy read version, the aphorism ‘I didn’t have time to write a short one’ is always apt.
On a related note, I see that the BSB have issued guidance on use of AI by barristers, which is well worth a read. A consultation by the Civil Procedure Rules Cttee on the use of AI has just closed (although it didn’t cover use by LiPs), and the use of AI in Family Courts will most certainly be on the agenda at the Family Procedure Rule Committee in coming months (see March Mins), though whether such a committee can, with the best will in the world, be nimble enough to catch up or keep up with the pace of change is unclear.
Sliding neatly across from one set of Rule Committee Minutes to the next, and to the topic of QLRs appointed to ask questions on behalf of litigants in person who are prohibited from asking questions themselves, the April minutes of the Rules Committee make for alarming reading on a number of levels. The changes to the statutory guidance proposed, the implied and explicit reasons such changes are thought necessary and the problems under discussion in that meeting suggest that all is not well with the QLR system. Not well at all. Another source of ‘help’ for the litigant in person, which may sometimes not be much help at all, it seems. Particularly were it to come to pass that a QLR simply reads out the AI generated questions presented to them by the Litigant in Person, or uses their own AI generated questions…
*actually, I’m just trying to fit in some time sensitive focus-intensive work, some bank hol relaxation anda blog post today, so that is the corner I chose to cut.
** I have just been brought a solero by my lovely husband, and solero’s are on my mind, ok?
The delicate politics of the automated reply
I've changed my out of office three times in the last couple of weeks. One change to say I was so busy that I might take some time to respond (this one offended someone who wasn't as busy and who presumably thought I was just being a show off and rubbing their nose in it) One change to say I was wearing another hat for a little while and wouldn't be looking specifically at chambers emails for a bit One more to politely explain to the people who seem to think that by some alchemy the combination of the words URGENT and INJUSTICE and CORRUPTION or BIAS will magically produce free and instantaneous legal advice based upon a long stream of consciousness email without so much as an eyelash at any papers - that in fact such enquiries need to go via my clerks, and anyway I'm too busy to take on such cases. This latter change was prompted by someone who read the first OOO and took it as a sign that they should simply send a second email, this time sprinkling in a few more of the magic words...
A confusing post-script
I came across an article in the Gazette this week with the headline: Judge issues pre-trial legal aid plea after mother left alone The article refers to this judgment of DJ Keating: London Borough of Sutton v A mother & Anor [2025] EWFC 147 (B) (bonus points to the Gazette for linking to it). The judgment is a final decision in care proceedings, and the first 97 paragraphs are the main decision and conclusion (the child was to remain living with extended family due to deficiencies in the mother's parenting). The article isn't about those, but is about the last 3 paragraphs, appearing under the heading 'other matters'. They are so short I'll repeat them in full: Other matters 98. I was told that M did not have the benefit of a conference with counsel to help prepare for what was a 4 day long contested final hearing. I am told that was because her lawyers had asked the legal aid agency to pay for 3 conferences, two of which took place at Court at an early stage of the proceedings,...
The small matter of fees
I know we're not supposed to mention fees. It's crass to talk about money - that's what clerks are for and all that. But now, it seems, we are expected to keep calm and carry on without any expectation of prompt payment of fees at all. An unspecified amount on an unspecified date. Many legal aid lawyers would say this has been the case for a long while now, so erratic is the legal aid payment system, but at least there was a process and a rule book. And in fact FAS claims, at least, were reasonably efficient. Now, as a result of the hacking of the Legal Aid Agency's systems, they can't see how much we are owed, can't accept new claims, and can't pay us. For an indefinite period of time, now acknowledged to be the situation for the foreseeable future. Here's the message we all got last week: It is unlikely that all services will be fully resolved in the short-term. As such we are now refining further plans for contingency, in the event that the need for contingency continues beyond...
Remembering Mr Banks
I know some would say I have a tendency to overshare, but I'm afraid it's hardwired, so look away now if that sort of thing makes you feel uncomfortable. There are some things I haven't shared though. The last few years have been...complicated at home. You will have seen oblique references to it here https://www.pinktape.co.uk/rants/the-beacon and here https://www.pinktape.co.uk/rants/what-are-we-doing-with-our-lives/ In September 2022 dad had a stroke. He had been caring for mum (to a far greater extent than we had realised because they hid the full extent of it from us, not wanting us to be worried). We took over from him, caring for mum at home for about a year until she moved in with us and the family home, now unoccupied and sad, had to be sold. And then Mum passed away in March last year. The two posts above relate to that period of selling the house and dealing with my mum's death. In May this year dad passed away too, after a pretty awful last month. We buried him last week....
Mea Culpa – a rather belated clarification
Some past version of me wrote a blog post in 2019, which someone recently reminded me of. It said that the family court can't order seizure of a device. Oh, I said glibly, I must have written that before the creation of the family court in 2014, because that definitely hasn't been the case since then. Except now I check, I wrote it in 2019. And the court definitely had those powers in 2019, by virtue of s31E Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984, as clarified by Re K, and FPR Part 20: 20.2 Orders for interim remedies (1) The court may grant the following interim remedies – (a) an interim injunction; (b) an interim declaration; (c) an order – (i) for the detention, custody or preservation of relevant property; (ii) for the inspection of relevant property; So, what did I actually say? The Family Court itself has no obvious realistic mechanism at its disposal to seize, download and analyse the contents of a digital device such as a smartphone in the absence of a criminal...
About this blog
“Pink Tape” isn’t just about family law. I post about topics that interest me, which mostly revolve around family law, but also include non-legal family-related topics as well as unrelated subjects. I hope this blog will convince at least one person that not all of us in the legal profession are money-hungry sharks. Some of us are actually quite nice. Additionally, I aim to provide useful information about family law for those working in the field without being too heavy or boring.
The primary goal of the blog is to improve the quality of public information and discussions about legal issues.
I understand that not everyone is a fan of “Pink Tape” or family lawyers in general.
latest
Blog Posts
Kirstie gets a telephone call from the social
I had a call earlier. Did I want to do a TV interview about Kirstie Allsopp and child protection? Er...on the Sunday afternoon of the August bank holiday weekend? To be quite honest, no. I've not got my face on and I'm in the middle of prepping for a trial, which...
X marks the spot?
It was the place where we all converged, at the centre of the social media map. But it all seems to be crumbling now. I flirted with mastodon a little while ago. Nobody really had the energy for it and it was dull as ditchwater, with suffocating etiquette to learn. We...
Looked After – A Childhood in Care
It's been a while since I've managed a book review. Because I'm always too absorbed in the job. I bought this book a couple of months ago, having read a review somewhere, and have been carrying it around in my backpack ever since. Unopened, naturally. There is always...
The ramblings of an old woman
The other day I was trawling back through very old Pink Tape posts looking for something I thought I'd written back in 2009. I was struck by how often I was writing on this blog, at at time when I was between babies and back at work. In one month there were about 20...
Resolution Podcast – Joshua Rozenberg, transparency – what’s not to like?
Ok, well it also features yours truly wibbling on about her pet topic again, but I'd like to think this episode of the excellent Resolution Podcast is interesting nonetheless. It was certainly fun to record, and Joshua as SUCH a total pro, reeling off all those on...
Controversial Suspected Inflicted Head Injuries pilot launched: Lawyers raise concern about lack of consultation and potential unfairness
To all care lawyers: There is an important post on The Transparency Project telling you about a new pilot that is running in Head Injury cases in Birmingham Sheffield and Manchester. When I say new, apparently its been live since April, not that anybody has been...
Pay what you owe or talk to the hand (what’s a Hadkinson order when it’s at home?)
The case of BR v SN provides an unusual example of court proactively controlling litigation about child arrangements against a backdrop of pretty relentless litigation, appeals and a failure to comply with orders made. After many earlier stages in the...
The presumption of parental involvement ten years on
‘Now is the time to reassess presumption of parental involvement’, writes Lea Levine in the April issue of the journal[1]. That’s what the Harm report said in 2020[2], and the Government agreed before commissioning an ‘urgent’ review of the legislative provisions in...
The value of nothing – why is the solution always a committee?
I've spent some time wrangling the weeds and the invasive species in my garden this bank holiday weekend. Digging out a giant bamboo that I once used to fill an inconvenient hole in my border and which has now formed an underground network of shoots that has taken...
Rules of the blog
Anonymized or fictional
All the information on this blog is anonymized or fictional to avoid causing any trouble for anyone, including myself. I have modified details to prevent the identification of specific cases.
Comments
I won’t approve comments that, in my judgment, breach privacy laws related to family matters. Unless individuals have been identified in a published judgment, I won’t disclose their involvement in any proceedings.
Nothing Defamatory
I will not post anything that I believe could be considered defamatory. Due to time constraints, I can’t fact-check every statement in a comment. Therefore, I must be cautious to prevent potential legal issues or threatening letters. If you’re certain that a comment is not defamatory, you can publish it elsewhere at your own risk.
NOT Legal Advice
The content of this blog is not intended to constitute legal advice, so please don’t interpret it as such. It may seem relevant to your situation, but it likely isn’t. I cannot be held responsible for any reliance you place on its contents.
Accuracy
The information on the blog is as accurate and up to date as possible, considering my other commitments. Pink Tape is a hobby that I work on when time allows. Therefore, I can’t cover all legal changes or update information that becomes outdated.
External Links
I cannot be held responsible for the content of external sites linked from this blog, in terms of their accuracy or the opinions expressed on them
Moderation
I’ve implemented comment moderation on this blog to filter out comments that are repeatedly negative or offensive about lawyers. Rest assured, I won’t block sensible contributions, even if they disagree with me. I will strive to moderate promptly, but occasionally a comment may get lost in spam.
Right of Reply
If a post contains an inaccuracy about you and you’d like it corrected, feel free to comment for a right of reply. Please respect that the content on this blog is my intellectual property, and ask for permission before reposting. If you have any topics or blog post suggestions, feel free to email me at familoo@pinktape.co.uk.
Copyright
All material on this site is copyright of Lucy Reed. Please do not reproduce without permission.
