What even IS Pink Tape?
Every time I have to explain to a youthful colleague what something now defunct was and how it used to work, I feel a little bit older…
This week I thoughtsomeone was mistakenly evangelical about the new marketing idea that is corners. (corners being the little cleverly die cut pieces of card, showing a chambers’ logo that one used to wrap around the corner of a skeleton argument before stapling, to make it look *mwah* and tip top!). As it turned out, in fact the image they had shared was of a digital corner on a digital document, which was rather a cute idea. Shoulda worn my varifocals…
But just as I was mentally dummy slapping myself for that misunderstanding, there came a comment about pink tape (the thing not the blog). Which really has now fallen out of use entirely (covid being the death knell). When I started this blog in 2007 pink tape was still a recognisable thing which had meaning, at least to the lawyers who read this blog, if not necessarily all the non-lawyers. But I realise that as every year passes fewer of my colleagues actually remember getting a brief tied in pink tape, or remember the paper explosions that would occur if you were insufficiently skilled or insufficiently careful in your tying. How many remember having drawers full of the stuff, and using it for everything from tying a ponytail, to stringing up beans, to attaching it on your suitcase so you could spot it on the carousel at the airport?
When I started Pink Tape the blog, it wasn’t with a wistful look back at the olden days. It was just an everyday thing, and a colour that, for me, was a semi-political statement signifying rebellion. I married in a bright pink wedding dress (I had some vague recollection of my grandmother idly commenting that if a woman didn’t get married in white it meant she was a *gasp* ‘Jesobel’, which sounded quite exciting)… and Pink Tape had resonance for me as I found my way into the strange world of the bar…Hence ‘Pink Tape’. Post covid, the eponymous heroine of this blog has faded out of recognition. It is a meaningless title to many. And I am struck how, in the 19 years since PT began, times have changed on so many fronts.
So I have wondered if, like me (and like its namesake), Pink Tape is getting a bit past it. Even the term ‘blog’ seems a bit quaint (I bet few readers remember when such things were called weblogs). Pink Tape the (we)blog doesn’t get much exercise these days, because the pace of life now our briefs arrive by email rather than neatly contained in tightly tied pink tape is just too much. And because, well, the older you get the more time you have to spend weighing up the risks and benefits and conducting a mental impact assessment before posting (rebelliously or otherwise)…that’s a mixture of wisdom, caution and the realisation that – inexplicably – the more senior you get the more power and authority you are wielding. ‘Ranting into the void’ is not so simple when people actually listen to what you have to say. With great power comes great responsibility. And so I have learnt to use my voice more thoughtfully. Impact is good. Unintended impact not always so.
And it does appear that some people are still listening to me blathering on (have you nothing better to do?) After a rare post a couple of weeks ago (the one about QLRs, not even especially interesting in the grand scheme of things) I’ve had about five people mention that they have read it and tell me they still read Pink Tape. When I responded with surprise to the last such comment I was told that everyonereads it. The stats remind me that this is flattery rather than fact, and that ‘everyone’ is quite a select few, but I guess I’m not quite rambling into a void, and I should probably try harder to say something worth reading.
My eldest beanpole came in for a chat as I was pondering this blog post. He is only slightly younger than Pink Tape (the blog) but remembered the pink tape strewn all about the house and garden. Even he asked me ‘mum, what was it forrrrrr?’. And so I told him about the different coloured tapes, about the neatly tied bundles that would arrive in the DX, with the words ‘BRIEF TO COUNSEL’ peeking out from under the pink cross and bow. I can visualise that pull of the tape end until the bow released with a satisfying thwunk, the ceremonial opening of the brief. The brief addressed to a proper barrister. The brief with my name on it. Pink tape was a surprisingly efficient document management tool, but it was also a sort of mystical ribbon that signified to me that – even as I felt like an outsider and an imposter – I was in fact an actual, proper barrister. And that there was something special about being one. Every day a new parcel an honour to receive – a little piece of a someone’s life inside, to be treated with care and respect. Each parcel containing a pink trussed mystery – something to investigate, to put together, to pull apart, to disentangle, a story to tell, a lie to uncover and a problem to solve.
It does make me a bit wistful when I think about how things were then. I mean, mostly I miss how I was then. I had more energy and a few more f*cks left to give, I suppose. I don’t especially miss having to do the daily trog from a far flung court back to chambers for the daily paper swap before travelling home again – the interminable wait for the fax machine to send your backsheet through to your solicitor after the hearing every day, trussing today’s brief back up neatly in pink tape ready for the DX, before retrieving the waiting brief for tomorrow from your pidge, ready for an evening of prep and mild panic. I don’t miss the inability to check anything once you got to court – the panic when you had no 10p pieces to put in the payphone in the advocates room so couldn’t call your solicitor to get emergency instructions (the panic when the payphone didn’t work anyway). I’m glad that we can all WhatsApp a mate and call in a phone a friend in the toilets these days. My back is pleased that we don’t have to carry six lever arch files full of papers across the country to court every day. I’m overjoyed that I no longer have to remember to print 3 copies of everything I might possibly need before I leave for court, and that I can research an unexpected point of law at court rather than being – frankly – stuffed unless I had the Red Book in my suitcase. I’m proud that our (my) understanding of domestic abuse and trauma (and vicarious trauma) has developed at last, whilst also being alarmed at how far it had to come and how far it still has to go.
I’m less overjoyed that counsel are no longer attended at court by a solicitor or outdoor clerk most of the time. And at the realisation that computers have somehow made the drafting of orders take much longer to prepare and use many more words. And at the overwhelming volume of emails, and the overwhelming volume of papers and digital evidence. And frankly, the overwhelming volume of ever more expectations. To prepare this, and draft that, all of which will make somebody else’s life easier. But never ours. No, “counsel will do it”. I am perhaps disillusioned that the march of scientific progress has brought the bar no more relief from drudgery than it did for the 50’s housewife. We can do amazing things with technology, but at the same time, the more of it we have the more that is demanded of us…an ever increasing proliferation of stuff for us to read and to write – and all of it to be done under ever greater time pressure in service of the gods of Efficiency and Timeliness.
So yes, the phrase ‘Pink Tape’ reminds me that an awful lot has changed during my working life, and the life of this blog, but not everything for the better. One thing that has never changed since before this barrister was one, is legal aid rates. The youngster coming up behind me, if they are willing to do family legal aid work at all, must do it at the same rates of pay that I received when I started back in 2002 (and the same rates that my more senior colleagues had been working at for some years before that). To be strictly accurate, they are being paid 90% of what young me was, due to the 10% across the board austerity cuts in 2011 (that 10% has never been restored). In fact, as the President of the Family Division retires next week around 30 years since he left the bar to become a judge, I can’t help but think about the fact that those junior colleagues will be paid no more than his contemporaries before his appointment. Because those rates haven’t changed at all, not even for inflation, for 30 years. Not a typo.
Those junior barristers, those modern me’s, may not need to be skilled tape-tiers or willing to be bundle pack horses, but my god they have to do a lot more for their money than we ever did. Tasks that weren’t a thing when the funding schemes were devised are expected to be done without payment, and just because we are dedicated to our job and our clients. The dwindling value of the fee and the privilege of working these cases is expected to be enough to motivate us. Enough to pay for our childcare and our mortgages, and to allow us to take time off (unpaid) to help us manage our vicarious trauma.
So as everything changes it also stays the same. In cold hard numbers the rates of pay are unchanged. But such is the effect of 30 years inflation, that the value of our pay and the value placed upon what we dois far lower than it was, and than we should expect. Our sense of duty at the bar is our greatest strength and our greatest weakness. And it has been exploited enough.
A learning experience
Two judgments have been circulating this week which reflect very badly on lawyers, or at any rate on two individual lawyers. I’ve been thinking a lot about them. They are uncomfortable reading for any lawyer and for any person who cares about justice. Because justice depends upon competence and ethics of lawyers and these judgments remind us that neither is a given. Though my 20 plus years of experience reassures me that the vast majority of lawyers are both good at what they do and trustworthy, there are exceptions and it’s simply no good to pretend otherwise. I speak from recent, depressing experience. Sometimes a lawyer is a perfectly good lawyer but just out of their depth in the particular case, or overburdened and overwhelmed through no fault of their own – these lawyers need more support and more experience. That support might be from line managers or from other more experienced colleagues, it might involve formal training, mentoring, support to help manage workloads,...
Can a judge make orders about a child who isn’t a subject of the proceedings?
Nope, say the Court of Appeal in a really interesting judgment delivered this week, in which my super colleague Olivia Pike argued and won the appeal. See E (Section 37 Direction, The Children Act 1989), [2025] EWCA Civ 470. I'm glad this has been cleared up because we all know that every so often a judge makes an order under s37 about a child that isn't the subject of the proceedings. Not that often, but often enough. The only wonder is that it hasn't been appealed and clarified before now. The wording of s37 is undoubtedly tempting for a judge with a legitimate concern about a child she has become aware of that is connected to the family that is before the court, but not actually a part of the case. A provision that appears to apply to 'any child' is an alluring solution to this problem. To my knowledge these orders are made from time to time, and the scenario in the appeal isn't an outlier - the court is often provided with information about other children in a household, who...
Necessity is the mother of intermediaries
Judgment was handed down this morning in Re M (A Child: Intermediaries) [2025] EWCA Civ 440. I had a small non-speaking part (for the FLBA). The judgment is a delightfully streamlined read and brings some welcome clarity to the approach on the appointment of intermediaries. As my - frankly fabulous - post title suggests, necessity is the test, baby. Nothing else will do: Not compelling. Not rare. Not exceptional. Just plain old necessary. Lord Justice Peter Jackson had this to say about the various high court authorities from which these high bar tests have emerged (before going on to politely demolish them): In the three appeals about intermediaries that it has heard since Part 3A came into effect, this court has taken its provisions at face value. Considering that the regulatory framework is recent, it is unpromising ground for a wider exercise in judicial interpretation. So, the various High Court authorities suggesting necessity plus in various flavours can be put to one side,...
Bristol Cable Podcast
The Bristol Cable Podcast interviewed some local girl about transparency recently. No idea who she is, but have a listen if you fancy. https://thebristolcable.org/2025/02/listen-bristol-unpacked-barrister-lucy-reed-opening-secretive-family-courts-to-scrutiny/ Also recommended is BBC Radio 4 short 10 part series 'You do not have to say anything' featuring criminal defence barrister and sausage dog owner Joanna Hardy Susskind, and some other stars of the criminal bar that you will want to hear from (I won't spoil it for you). Really good explanation of how it works (and doesn't). Listen here. Lots more has been happening this week - New Guidance on judges writing letters to children (a big thumbs up on that), a reminder that we shouldn't be 'citing' cases that aren't citable (generally decisions of Circuit Judges and below aren't citable, just interesting!), and covert recording guidance... oh no, wait. Not that last one....
I may have been gone some time…
Posts are getting ever more infrequent around here. Doubtless in part because of my continuing inability to say 'no'. Having been on the verge of being virtually committee-less at the end of last year, I now find myself back on two committees (FLBA, Bar Council). The Transparency Project work continues, and I seem to be forever scrambling to keep on top of that. I am desperate to find some time to do more legal blogging (my last outing in October has been stuck in the mud for reasons I can't tell you about at the moment, so I've nothing to show for my endeavours on that front), and I've been flat out with work since December. On top of all that there has been lots happening at home so there is much to juggle. All excuses of course. I used to manage multiple posts a week whilst wrangling two toddlers and writing a book. I smile weakly whenever someone says to me 'Oh, I don't know how you manage it all', knowing of course that approximately once a week a plate goes careering off its...
About this blog
“Pink Tape” isn’t just about family law. I post about topics that interest me, which mostly revolve around family law, but also include non-legal family-related topics as well as unrelated subjects. I hope this blog will convince at least one person that not all of us in the legal profession are money-hungry sharks. Some of us are actually quite nice. Additionally, I aim to provide useful information about family law for those working in the field without being too heavy or boring.
The primary goal of the blog is to improve the quality of public information and discussions about legal issues.
I understand that not everyone is a fan of “Pink Tape” or family lawyers in general.
latest
Blog Posts
“Paedophiles to lose parental rights” – but what does that actually mean?
[UPDATE - there is an update at the end of this post] Last week, I found myself unexpectedly recording an episode of BBC Newscast with Sanchia Berg and Harriet Harman MP. The prompt for the episode was a reform to legislation proposed by Harriet Harman, supported by...
Please don’t confuse your ‘usual practice’ with my actual reading of the actual rules
Alright you slackers, it's time for some law. Mainly because I have had a bunch of browser windows open with 'new' judgments open, ready for me to write them up and I can't tick them off my to do list until I do. I could just close the browser windows but that would...
What are we doing with our lives?
I've been cautious about posting anything recently. My head is awl of a muddle and I may say something I will later regret. But I've got itchy fingers and am sitting quietly at home with nobody to distract me, so... I should be at work this week. In fact I should be...
I have run out of vases
Trigger warning: death. My mum died last week. Her name was Suzanne (never Susan). I realised as I studied her face after it happened that I have never seen a dead body before. Her top lip was taut over her teeth. She looked weirdly waxen. Her forehead was cool...
What my out of office really means…
The other day I put a polite but hopefully firm OOO on my emails, explaining that I am not taking on new work and will deal only with emails relating to existing commitments. This morning I seriously contemplated rewording it to simply read: "For the love of god,...
Two more books, still working on that novel…
Hot on the heels of the second edition of Transparency in the Family Courts, released last week, I received these beauties in the post today. The Public Law Dictionary is a new addition to this family of dictionaries, and I am one of the authors. Other titles include...
Transparency in the Family Courts – Publicity and Privacy in Practice
I'm please to say that the Second Edition of our book Transparency in the Family Court - Publicity and Privacy in Practice is now available for pre-order from Bloomsbury Professional Press for £85. This time around it comes in a fetching shade of pond green. As you...
In defence of tit for tat
I've been blessed with some lovely cooperative and charming opponents recently. And few who have been grouchy, rude and irrational. I'm a firm believer that being that person doesn't pay off: it isn't an effective strategy that assists clients. It signals a loss of...
The Beacon
The light over the front door flickers at The Beacon. There is a bit of damp creeping up the plaster and into the wiring. My dad would have fixed it, but he hasn't been there for a year. There is a 'sold' sign at the top of the drive and my heart is breaking. The...
Rules of the blog
Anonymized or fictional
All the information on this blog is anonymized or fictional to avoid causing any trouble for anyone, including myself. I have modified details to prevent the identification of specific cases.
Comments
I won’t approve comments that, in my judgment, breach privacy laws related to family matters. Unless individuals have been identified in a published judgment, I won’t disclose their involvement in any proceedings.
Nothing Defamatory
I will not post anything that I believe could be considered defamatory. Due to time constraints, I can’t fact-check every statement in a comment. Therefore, I must be cautious to prevent potential legal issues or threatening letters. If you’re certain that a comment is not defamatory, you can publish it elsewhere at your own risk.
NOT Legal Advice
The content of this blog is not intended to constitute legal advice, so please don’t interpret it as such. It may seem relevant to your situation, but it likely isn’t. I cannot be held responsible for any reliance you place on its contents.
Accuracy
The information on the blog is as accurate and up to date as possible, considering my other commitments. Pink Tape is a hobby that I work on when time allows. Therefore, I can’t cover all legal changes or update information that becomes outdated.
External Links
I cannot be held responsible for the content of external sites linked from this blog, in terms of their accuracy or the opinions expressed on them
Moderation
I’ve implemented comment moderation on this blog to filter out comments that are repeatedly negative or offensive about lawyers. Rest assured, I won’t block sensible contributions, even if they disagree with me. I will strive to moderate promptly, but occasionally a comment may get lost in spam.
Right of Reply
If a post contains an inaccuracy about you and you’d like it corrected, feel free to comment for a right of reply. Please respect that the content on this blog is my intellectual property, and ask for permission before reposting. If you have any topics or blog post suggestions, feel free to email me at familoo@pinktape.co.uk.
Copyright
All material on this site is copyright of Lucy Reed. Please do not reproduce without permission.
